Skip to main content

WHY WE BROKE UP by Daniel Handler



copyright date: 2011
primarily marketed for: young adults (high school)

Every once in awhile a book this good finds its way into my hands.  Every once in awhile.  I hope it may find its way into yours. 

Everything about this book is appealing: 
·      The fact that it is by Daniel Handler, perhaps better known as Lemony Snicket. 
·      The fact that each chapter is illustrated with wondrously fun art by Maira Kalman (illustrator also of 13 Words and Fireboat- two of my picture book favorites). 
·      The fact that it begins: “Dear Ed,” and ends: “Love, Min”. 
·      The fact that the pages are a heavy glossy paper that makes the weight of the book as substantial as the story inside and just plain feels good to touch. 
·      The fact that it is written in the form of a list of objects that fill a box of mementos of a relationship that we start the book knowing has already ended, and yet we don’t give up hope that somehow the inevitable ending will be avoided. 
·      The fact that Daniel Handler has this way of writing—this way of writing that almost makes me think he is Australian, even though he’s not (proof of Handler’s almost Australian way of writing by making words work in unexpected ways that are dead-on: “But all I remember is the music fading, vengefully turned down so it no longer sound-tracked the day.”) 
·      The fact that reading this story made me feel exposed as the awkward human I am, and yet made me feel comforted that I am not alone—I am an awkward human amongst awkward humans who are experiencing similar feelings in painfully similar situations (the essence of them is similar anyway). 
·      The fact that even though it touches on really mature subjects and uses mature language and seems to just accept that all high school students are underage drinkers, it honestly communicates a life lesson about relationships that is soberingly true and necessary for us all to learn—and wouldn’t it be wonderful if we could all learn it vicariously through Daniel Handler’s fictitious relationship in this book instead of learning it the hard way?
·      The fact that the protagonist, whose voice is instantly endearing, has a passion for French movies and can’t help but reference applicable scenes from them—scenes from movies that, to the best of my knowledge, are entirely fabricated from Handler’s own imagination, making their obscurity that much more absurd.
·      The fact that this book has illustrated endpages—how many YA books have illustrated endpages?
·      The fact that this book has its own tumblr page.

Enough said.

Comments

  1. Nice style of reviewing, Christy, & the book sounds great. I'll certainly keep it in mind. Here's one rec for you: Dash & Lily's Book of Dares. Your students might like it for the relationship angle too.

    ReplyDelete
  2. This sounds terrific. I can think of several hands to put it in! Thanks for this!

    ReplyDelete

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

I HUNT KILLERS by Barry Lyga

copyright date: April 2012 primarily marketed for: young adults (high school) I’m just going to put this out there:  I like books about death.  I didn’t know this about myself as a reader until my students this year pointed out how many of the books I booktalk (basically all of them) involve someone who died or someone who is dying. I am not sure if that is just a me thing, or if that is a common thread in books since it is such a major part of life and conflict.  I’d like to think it is the latter. At any rate, I Hunt Killers by Barry Lyga , is obviously my kind of book—it is quality literature with sophisticated vocabulary, and it is about death.  Jasper Dent, known as Jazz, is a teenager who is struggling to overcome the odds, to say the least.  His father, Billy Cornelius Dent, is the most infamous serial killer, with victims totaling triple digits.  Since his father’s arrest, Jazz has had to care for his grandmother ...

JAKE AND LILY by Jerry Spinelli

copyright date: May 2012 primarily marketed for: intermediate readers (8 and up) This is another book for younger readers.   So, although the time you spend actually reading Jake and Lily by Jerry Spinelli won’t be long, the time this story spends traveling around in your heart will be immeasurable. Spinelli is a master at getting straight to the heart of what keeps people from accepting one another: differences.   Through the story of young twins Jake and Lily, he tells a story of tolerance, acceptance, and ultimately friendship.   Jake and Lily have a very special relationship.   They are able to connect with one another through dreams and across distances.   In fact, as they write their stories for us in alternating chapters, they don’t even need to read to know what they other has written.   Conflict settles into their lives when growing up threatens to come between them.   As Jake begins to spend more time with a g...

NOTHING SPECIAL by Geoff Herbach

copyright date: May 2012 primarily marketed for: young adults (12 and up) This is Geoff Herbach 's sequel to Stupid Fast and continues Felton Reinstein’s story in true Felton fashion.   This is definitely a smart guy book—a book for smart guys, who definitely love a good chuckle. The story opens at the end of summer with Felton typing a letter to his girlfriend Aleah while flying in an airplane on his way to retrieve his younger brother from Florida.   The entire book is written as one giant letter to Aleah explaining how his summer led him to this moment in time.   After Felton and his brother Andrew got some help with their mother’s issues, Felton went right back to throwing himself into football and track—because he is stupid fast.   However, Andrew did not cope quite as well as Felton did.   Felton ignores his brother’s cries for help and continuously lets him down.   His brother ends up cooking up an elaborate plan to run ...